FIRE Dashboard

Does the 4% rule work in the Netherlands?

The 4% rule is the best-known rule of thumb in FIRE: withdraw 4% of your starting wealth every year and your wealth lasts 30 years. But the rule comes from the United States, without a wealth tax and for a retirement of 30 years. If you stop at 45 in the Netherlands, things are different.

In short

  • The 4% rule worked in almost all historical 30-year periods in the US, with a mix of shares and bonds.
  • If you stop young, your wealth has to last longer than 30 years. Many people pursuing FIRE therefore use 3 to 3.5%.
  • In 2026, box 3 tax on invested wealth easily costs 1.5 to 2% a year. That tax comes on top of what you withdraw.
  • The state pension (AOW) shortens the period in which your wealth has to pay for everything. That works the other way.

Where the rule comes from

In 1994 the American financial planner William Bengen investigated how much you could withdraw each year without your wealth running out within 30 years, even in the worst historical periods. In 1998 came the Trinity study by three professors, with the same question and similar results. The rule works like this:

  1. In the first year you withdraw 4% of your starting wealth.
  2. Every year after that you increase that amount by inflation, regardless of how the stock market does.
  3. You invest in a mix of shares and bonds.

In reverse, the rule gives the well-known FIRE number: 25 times your annual expenses. More on this in calculating your FIRE number.

Three differences in the Netherlands

1. Your horizon is longer than 30 years

The research was about people who stopped at around 65. If you stop at 45, your wealth may have to last 45 years. The longer the period, the lower the rate that always worked historically. That is why many early retirees choose 3 to 3.5%.

2. Box 3 comes off every year

In the US you only pay tax when you sell. In the Netherlands you pay box 3 tax on your wealth on 1 January, every year. In 2026, investments have a deemed return (fictief rendement) of 6%, taxed at 36%, above the tax-free allowance (heffingsvrij vermogen). With €500,000 in investments and savings, that is €7,500 to €9,000 a year in 2026, depending on the split and whether you have a tax partner (fiscale partner); with €1 million in investments, about €20,300. That is money that leaves your wealth without you spending it.

You can include it in two ways: add the box 3 tax to your expenses, or choose a lower withdrawal rate. How box 3 works exactly is explained in calculating box 3 in 2026.

3. The AOW takes over part of it

From your AOW age you receive a basic pension from the government, and often a pension from your employer as well. Your wealth then no longer has to carry all your expenses. The heavy years are therefore those between your FIRE date and your AOW age. See bridging the AOW gap.

So which rate do you choose?

A rule of thumb is no substitute for a calculation, but the table shows how much the rate matters.

Withdrawal rateFIRE number (times your expenses)At €30,000 a year
4.5%22.2€666,667
4%25€750,000
3.5%28.6€857,143
3.25%30.8€923,077
3%33.3€1,000,000

Better than choosing a single rate is looking at the chance that it works out. A Monte Carlo simulation plays out a thousand possible futures, with good and bad years on the stock market in random order. You then see the success rate: in how many of those futures your wealth lasts. The first years after your FIRE date count most: a few bad years right after you stop do more damage than later ones. This is called sequence risk. How such a simulation works, and how to read the result, is in Monte Carlo simulation explained.

Flexible withdrawals help too. If you spend a little less for a while after a bad year on the stock market, you can start with a higher rate.

Sources

A calculation aid, not financial advice. Past returns are no guarantee of future results.