FIRE Dashboard

ETFs or individual shares for your FIRE plan

You can pick shares yourself, or buy a whole index with a single fund. For a plan spanning decades, what matters most is how well you are diversified and what it costs. This guide sets out the differences, and what Dutch tax changes about them.

In short

  • A global index fund such as an MSCI World ETF holds more than 1,200 companies. With individual shares you rarely get close to that diversification.
  • The stock market's return comes from few shares. In the US, 58% of shares did worse over their whole listed life than short-term government bills.
  • Costs add up. With 0.8 percentage points more in costs a year, after 30 years of investing you have about €66,000 less in our example.
  • In box 3 your choice makes no difference today. With individual foreign shares you offset the withheld dividend tax yourself; with a fund it happens inside the fund.

What the difference is

An ETF (exchange-traded fund) is an investment fund you buy and sell on the stock exchange, just like a share. An index fund tracks an index, such as the MSCI World: it buys all the companies in that index, in proportion to their size. You do not choose which companies, but which market.

With individual shares you choose the companies yourself, and how much of each. You also decide when to buy and sell.

Diversification

On 30 September 2026 the MSCI World held 1,249 companies from 23 developed countries. One fund gives you all of them. Someone picking shares usually has far fewer, because every company needs its own order and its own attention.

That difference matters more than it seems. Research by Hendrik Bessembinder into all US shares from 1926 to 2016 showed that 58% of shares earned less over their whole listed life than short-term US government bills. All the extra wealth the stock market created came from just over 4% of companies. With a handful of shares, there is a real chance you miss the winners. An index fund holds them by definition.

An index fund is not evenly spread either. In the MSCI World, the ten largest companies made up 27.85% of the index on 30 September 2026, mostly US tech companies. So diversification across countries and sectors is worth checking with a fund too.

Costs

With a fund you pay ongoing charges, as a percentage per year. They are in the fund's key information document. On top of that you pay your broker transaction costs on every purchase and sale, and the difference between the bid and ask price (the spread).

Individual shares have no ongoing charges, but you make more transactions: a separate order for each company, and more often when you top up or rebalance. With small amounts per order, fixed costs weigh heavily.

Worked example: costs over 30 years

You invest €6,000 a year for 30 years, at the start of each year. We assume the investment returns 6% a year before costs, and leave tax out here. We compare costs of 0.2% a year with 1.0%, for example a low-cost index fund against a more expensive active fund.

0.2% costs1.0% costs
Total invested: 30 × €6,000€180,000€180,000
Return after costs5.8%5.0%
Wealth after 30 years€484,541€418,565

Work it out with your own numbers, for free

The difference is €65,976, more than a third of everything you put in. At a withdrawal rate of 4% a year, that is over €2,600 a year in income. Costs are one of the few parts of your return you control.

Time and behaviour

Individual shares need upkeep. You follow annual reports and news, and you keep deciding whether to hold, buy more or sell. That can be fun, but it takes time, and every decision is a chance to trade too much or sell in a panic.

An index fund needs almost nothing: you top up monthly and check a few times a year whether your allocation is still right. For a FIRE plan that has to keep working after you stop, that is an advantage.

Tax

In box 3 you pay tax in 2026 on a deemed return of 6.00% on your investments. Whether those are individual shares or a fund makes no difference to the assessment. The calculation is in calculating box 3 tax.

The difference lies in dividend tax:

  • Individual Dutch shares: the company usually withholds 15% dividend tax (dividendbelasting). You offset it against your income tax.
  • Individual foreign shares: the other country often withholds tax at source. You may offset it in your Dutch tax return, up to the rate in the tax treaty and up to the part of your Dutch tax that belongs to that income. Anything withheld above that, you reclaim in the other country.
  • A fund: the fund receives the dividends itself, and whatever the other country withholds is paid by the fund. You do not offset that in your own tax return. How much it costs depends on where the fund is based and which treaties that country has. So look not only at the ongoing charges, but also at how closely the fund tracks its index.

From 2029 the cabinet wants a capital gains tax (vermogenswinstbelasting) on shares and funds, taxing price gains when you sell. This is a plan, not yet law. It applies to individual shares and funds in the same way. What it means for dividends is in dividend or growth.

What to do with this

  1. Make a broad index fund your basis. It gives the diversification that is hard to reach with individual shares, at low cost and for little time.
  2. Compare funds on ongoing charges and on how closely they track their index. Both are in the fund's documents.
  3. If you still want individual shares, keep that part small. Base your FIRE plan on the fund, and treat the individual shares as extra.
  4. Keep track of your dividend tax. With individual shares, the tax withheld is on your broker's annual statement. You need it for your tax return.