Actual return in box 3
Box 3 uses a deemed return (fictief rendement). If you actually earned less, you only have to pay tax on that lower return. You arrange this through the counter-evidence scheme (tegenbewijsregeling). Meanwhile, the cabinet wants to tax box 3 differently from 2029: with a tax on capital gains when you sell.
In short
- If your actual return is lower than the deemed return, you pay 36% on the lower amount.
- Actual return is everything you earned, including price gains on investments you have not yet sold.
- From tax year 2025 it is part of the tax return; the Dutch Tax Administration (Belastingdienst) chooses the most favourable outcome.
- The counter-evidence scheme stays in place in 2027 and 2028.
- From 2029 the cabinet wants a capital gains tax for shares, funds, bonds and property. That is in the amending bill of 3 November 2026. The House of Representatives passed it on 12 November 2026; the Senate still has to vote. So it is not law yet.
- From 2029 the 2027 tax plan (Belastingplan 2027) brings two rates: 35.5% on the first €60,000 of taxable income from savings and investments per year, and 38.5% above that. The Senate still has to approve this too.
How the counter-evidence scheme works
Following rulings by the Supreme Court (Hoge Raad), you may show that your actual return was lower than the deemed return. If you succeed, your box 3 tax is calculated on the lower return. A few rules:
- Everything counts. Interest, dividends, rent, and the change in value of your assets, even if you sold nothing. A year with price gains on the stock market therefore produces actual return.
- There is no tax-free allowance (heffingsvrij vermogen) for actual return. You pay tax on the entire actual return.
- It is a choice. You do not have to do it; only if it results in lower tax.
- For 2017 to 2024 you use the Opgaaf werkelijk rendement form. From tax year 2025, it is part of the tax return itself.
When it pays off
Mainly in years when the stock market falls or stays flat, and with a lot of savings at a low interest rate. In a normal or good year on the stock market, the actual return on investments is usually above the 6% the Belastingdienst uses, and it does not help. So keep track of the value of your assets on 1 January, and of the interest and dividends you receive; then you can work it out afterwards.
For a FIRE plan, it means that box 3 is lower in bad years. That is favourable, because it is precisely in those years that every euro that stays in your wealth counts. See also sequence risk and the 4% rule.
The new box 3 law
The current box 3 is a transitional scheme. A new law is meant to have box 3 tax the actual return, including price gains on investments you have not yet sold. The House of Representatives (Tweede Kamer) passed that law on 12 February 2026. The planned start was 1 January 2028, already postponed once from 2027.
In the Senate (Eerste Kamer) there was too little support for taxing gains you have not sold yet. So the cabinet wants to change the bill with an amending bill (novelle): a change to a bill that is already before the Senate. The cabinet submitted it on 3 November 2026.
The amending bill of 3 November 2026
A bill, passed by the House of Representatives on 12 November 2026, not yet by the Senate.
- From 2029: for all financial instruments, such as shares, bonds, funds and ETFs, and for property, you pay tax on price gains when you sell. Interest, dividends and rent are taxed every year. What you already own on 1 January 2029 gets its value on that day as its purchase price.
- Savings, crypto and other assets such as gold: in 2029 their change in value over the year is taxed, even without a sale. From 2030 the cabinet wants to bring them under the capital gains tax as well, with a separate bill.
- Tax-free result €1,800 per person, as in the actual return bill. Costs are deductible, and you can offset losses against later years. The rate was 36%; the House of Representatives chose two rates, see below.
- 2027 and 2028: the current system with the counter-evidence scheme stays. The plan from the letter to parliament of 29 September 2026 to lower the tax-free allowance (heffingsvrij vermogen) in 2027 to €30,846 and raise the deemed return to 7.87% has been dropped. The lower tax-free result of €1,000 is also off.
The cabinet first wanted to start in 2028. The Council of State (Raad van State) does not consider that responsible based on the information available, and the Belastingdienst calls it unworkable. The cabinet is still looking at whether 2028 might work after all.
Unlike under the actual return law, you would not pay tax on price gains you have not yet sold. For someone pursuing FIRE, the tax moves to the years in which you sell to live on the money. There is a worked example in box 3 in 2027 and 2028.
What the House of Representatives decided on 12 November 2026
The House of Representatives passed the amending bill, with the support of 50PLUS, D66, CDA, VVD, SGP, JA21, BBB, Lid Keijzer and Groep Markuszower. The same evening it passed the 2027 tax plan by 76 votes to 74. For investors, three decisions matter.
- Two rates from 2029. An amendment by Klaver and Dassen to the 2027 tax plan sets the box 3 rate at 35.5% on the first €60,000 of taxable income from savings and investments per year, and 38.5% on the part above that. It applies from 1 January 2029: in the actual return law if that bill becomes law, and otherwise in the current law. In 2027 and 2028 the rate stays 36%.
- Property costs deductible. An amendment by Grinwis, Stoffer and Vermeer to the amending bill makes costs for real estate deductible in the counter-evidence scheme. At the moment costs do not count there. The cabinet sets the start date; according to the authors it cannot be earlier than 2028.
- A full capital gains tax. An adopted motion by Hoogeveen and others asks the cabinet to submit a bill for the full capital gains tax, so also for crypto and other assets such as gold, by Budget Day (Prinsjesdag) 2027 at the latest, and to introduce it by 1 January 2030 at the latest. A motion is a request, not law.
What two rates mean
Taxable income from savings and investments is your result for the year minus the tax-free result. Up to €72,000 you pay less with two rates than with 36%, above that more. At €72,000 it is the same: you save 0.5% on €60,000 (€300) and pay 2.5% extra on €12,000 (€300).
| Taxable income from savings and investments | 36% | 35.5% and 38.5% | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| €20,000 | €7,200 | €7,100 | −€100 |
| €60,000 | €21,600 | €21,300 | −€300 |
| €72,000 | €25,920 | €25,920 | €0 |
| €100,000 | €36,000 | €36,700 | +€700 |
The threshold applies per person. With the capital gains tax, a sale only counts the gain on the part you sell, not the whole amount. If you live off your assets and sell part of them every year, the taxed amount is therefore smaller than what you withdraw. The higher rate mainly affects you in a year with a large sale, such as a house or a large block of shares with a big gain. Spread such a sale over several years and more of the gain falls under the lower rate.
What still has to happen
The amending bill, the actual return bill and the 2027 tax plan are now before the Senate. Its finance committee discusses the procedure on 17 November 2026; there is no date for the vote yet. Only when the Senate agrees does it become law. For a plan spanning decades, use current law, and look at what the proposal would do. How box 3 works in 2026 is in box 3 in 2026.
Sources
- Belastingdienst: what is my actual return? (in Dutch)
- Dutch government (Rijksoverheid): timeline for actual return in box 3 (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: bill, amending bill on extending the capital gains tax in box 3 (Kamerstuk 37053) (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: explanatory memorandum to the amending bill (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: advice of the Council of State and the cabinet's response (28 October 2026, in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: Belastingdienst implementation assessment (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: cabinet letter of 3 November 2026 (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: actual return bill (36748-2) (PDF, in Dutch)
- Senate: box 3 actual return bill (36.748), progress (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: vote on the amending bill (37053), 12 November 2026 (in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: record of the final votes on the 2027 tax plan and the amending bill, 12 November 2026 (Word, in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: record of the votes on amendments and motions, 12 November 2026 (Word, in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: amendment by Klaver and Dassen, two rates in box 3 (37022, no. 80) (Word, in Dutch)
- House of Representatives: amendment by Grinwis and others, cost deduction for real estate in box 3 (37053, no. 14) (Word, in Dutch)
- Senate: amending bill extending the capital gains tax in box 3 (37.053), progress (in Dutch)
- Senate: 2027 tax plan (37.022), progress (in Dutch)
A calculation aid, not financial advice. As of 16 November 2026; the amending bill and the 2027 tax plan have been passed by the House of Representatives, not yet by the Senate. The plans for box 3 change quickly; check the latest on the Rijksoverheid website.