FIRE Dashboard

Monte Carlo with a BV: how the simulation handles your holding company

If part of your wealth is in a BV, a euro in the BV is not the same as a euro in your personal account. What is in the BV is not taxed in box 3, but before you can live on it, you pay corporate income tax (vpb) and box 2. That is why the Monte Carlo simulation in FIRE Dashboard works with two pots. This is how it works.

In short

  • The simulation keeps personal wealth and the BV apart. Box 3 applies to personal wealth only.
  • What you take out of the BV reaches you as a dividend: first vpb on the capital gain of what the BV sells, then box 2. Your paid-in capital comes back tax-free first.
  • The BV pays vpb every year on the interest on savings it holds.
  • Rebalancing happens within each pot: money from the BV to you is always a payout.

Why a BV is different

In personal wealth you pay box 3 on your assets every year, and after that the money is yours to spend. In a BV it is the other way round: no box 3, but the BV pays vpb on its profit, and you pay box 2 as soon as it pays you anything. A simulation that treats all your wealth as personal wealth does not see that tax when you withdraw, and so looks too favourable.

2026Personal wealthIn the BV
Every yearBox 3 on your savings and investmentsVpb on the interest on savings: 19% up to €200,000, 25.8% above
On a saleNothing extraVpb on the capital gain
Paid to youNothing extraBox 2 on the dividend: 24.5% up to €68,843, 31% above

Try it with your own numbers, free

What the simulation does each year

The simulation plays out your years after your FIRE date a thousand times or more, just as without a BV. The difference is in what happens to your wealth each year:

  1. Two pots. Each asset class, such as savings or shares, is either in personal wealth or in the BV, with its own expected return and its own spread.
  2. Withdrawing pro rata. What you need for your spending, minus your AOW and pension, comes from both pots in proportion to their value. If one pot cannot cover its share, the other takes over.
  3. Paying out from the BV. For the part from the BV, the BV sells enough that sufficient money is left after vpb and box 2. It pays vpb on the part of the sale that is capital gain. Then your paid-in capital comes back tax-free, and you pay box 2 on the rest.
  4. Returns. Each asset class gets a random year. The BV pays vpb straight away on the interest on its savings; investments in the BV only pay vpb when they are sold.
  5. Box 3 on personal wealth. The tax applies only to what is in personal wealth. If that is too small to pay the bill, the BV pays out the difference.
  6. Rebalancing within each pot. Personal wealth goes back to the mix it started with, and the BV to the BV's mix. Money never moves from the BV to you tax-free.

The vpb and box 2 rates follow the tax year. If the app calculates with the plans for box 2, the lower rates of 23.5% and 29% in 2027–2030 also apply in the simulation.

A worked example

Say you want to take €10,000 net out of the BV this year, and your paid-in capital has already been repaid. How much the BV has to sell depends on what it sells:

Savings in the BVShares, half of it gain
Sold in the BV€13,245€14,635
Vpb on the capital gain (19%)€0−€1,390
Dividend€13,245€13,245
Box 2 (24.5%)−€3,245−€3,245
Net in personal wealth€10,000€10,000

On savings in the BV, the vpb has already been paid each year, on the interest. That is why only box 2 is added when it is sold. With shares, the vpb is still in the capital gain and you only pay it on a sale. If you still have paid-in capital left, box 2 is lower: that part comes back tax-free first.

Starting net or gross

The simulation starts with your FIRE number, split the way your wealth is split today. If Use net value is on in your profile, the app compares your FIRE number with your wealth after the tax still held in the BV. The simulation then does the same: the BV part starts at the gross amount that leaves your share of the FIRE number after vpb and box 2.

An example: if €500,000 of your FIRE number belongs in the BV, in savings and without paid-in capital, the BV starts at about €718,150 in the simulation. Paying that out in one go costs 24.5% box 2 on the first €68,843 and 31% on the rest, which leaves €500,000. That is on the cautious side: paying out over many years keeps more of it in the lower rate. If net value is off, the BV simply starts at its share of the FIRE number.

How to read the result

You read the success rate, the median and the percentiles just as without a BV; see Monte Carlo simulation explained. Two things are different:

  • The wealth in the chart is gross. What is in the BV counts as it stands, without the vpb and box 2 you still pay when it is paid out.
  • A BV both costs and saves tax. There is no box 3 on the BV, but every withdrawal from it pays vpb and box 2. Which side weighs more depends on your return, your purchase price and how much you take out each year.

In the SWR panel, the asset classes in the BV are listed separately, for example Equities in the BV, with their weight, expected return and spread. The stress tests use the same two pots.

What the simulation does not do

  • No order of its own. The simulation withdraws from both pots pro rata. Which pot is best to use first, you compare in the withdrawal order in Pro.
  • No customary salary or BV costs. Salary from the BV, the bookkeeper and the annual accounts are not included.
  • Today's rules. The simulation uses the rates the app knows for each year. Thirty years from now, they will almost certainly be different.
  • Not advice. With a BV, the amounts are large. Have your plan checked by a tax adviser or your accountant.