FIRE Dashboard

Pay off your mortgage or invest?

If you have money to spare, you can overpay your mortgage or invest it. Overpaying gives a certain return: the interest you no longer pay, minus the tax relief you lose. Investing is expected to earn more, but without certainty, and with box 3 on top. For anyone who wants to stop early, the calculation changes on the day the salary stops.

In short

  • Overpaying earns the mortgage interest, minus the mortgage interest relief (hypotheekrenteaftrek). In 2026 that relief is at most 37.56%.
  • Investing earns your return, minus box 3: in 2026 that is 2.16% of your investments a year, if you are above the tax-free allowance.
  • With a 3.8% mortgage rate and a top-bracket income, your investment return has to beat about 4.5% to win over overpaying.
  • After your FIRE date the relief is often worth almost nothing. Overpaying then earns the full interest, and the balance tips.

What overpaying earns

If you pay off an extra €10,000, you no longer pay interest on that amount. But your mortgage interest is deductible in box 1, so you also get less tax back. Your net saving is the interest times (1 minus your deduction rate).

  • The deduction rate. With an income in the first bracket (up to €38,883 in 2026) you deduct at 35.75%. Above that, at 37.56%. Even if you are in the 49.5% bracket, the relief is worth no more than 37.56%.
  • The deemed rental value (eigenwoningforfait). For a home with a WOZ value between €75,000 and €1,350,000 you add 0.35% of that value to your income. With a WOZ value of €450,000 that is €1,575 a year. As long as you pay more interest than that, overpaying does not change it.
  • The Hillen rule (Wet Hillen). If your interest is lower than the deemed rental value, for example because you have paid off almost everything, you may deduct 71.867% of the difference in 2026. By law that percentage drops by 4.8 percentage points every year; in 2027 it is 67.067%. So a paid-off home costs you a little more tax each year.
  • The 30 years. If you took out your first mortgage on or after 1 January 2013, you can deduct the interest for at most 30 years, and you have to repay it at least on an annuity or linear basis.

If you pay off everything, you pay tax on the part of the deemed rental value that the Hillen rule does not cancel. With a WOZ value of €450,000, that is €443 of extra income in 2026: €1,575 minus 71.867% of it. At 49.5% that is €219 a year.

What investing earns

What you invest falls into box 3. If your wealth is already above the tax-free allowance (heffingsvrij vermogen) of €59,357 per person, every extra euro of investments costs you 36% of a deemed return of 6% in 2026. That is 2.16% a year, whether your investments rise or fall. How that works is explained in calculating box 3 tax in 2026. If your actual return was lower, you can show that; see actual return in box 3.

The reverse is also true. Money you take out of your investments to pay off the mortgage leaves box 3. Your home is in box 1, so your box 3 tax goes down. If the money comes from your savings account, the difference is smaller: the deemed return on bank balances is 1.28%, so 0.46% tax a year.

Worked example

You are single, still working, with a taxable salary of €90,000. Your mortgage is still €250,000, at 3.8% interest, on a home with a WOZ value of €450,000. You already have €300,000 in ETFs. You have €50,000 to spare. For investing we assume a return of 5% a year, after costs and before tax. That is an assumption, not a promise.

OverpayInvest
Interest you no longer pay: 3.8% × €50,000€1,900–
Less mortgage interest relief: 37.56% × €1,900−€714–
Expected return: 5% × €50,000–€2,500
Box 3: 36% × 6% × €50,000–−€1,080
Net per year, while you work€1,186 (2.37%)€1,420 (2.84%)
Net per year, after your FIRE date with no box 1 income€1,900 (3.80%)€1,420 (2.84%)

While you work, investing wins by €234 a year in this example, if the 5% return is achieved. The break-even point is a return of 4.53%: 2.37% for overpaying plus 2.16% box 3. After overpaying, your interest is still above the deemed rental value of €1,575, so the Hillen rule does not apply yet.

After your FIRE date you live off your wealth and often have no salary. With no other income in box 1, there is nothing to deduct from, and the relief is worth nothing. Overpaying then saves the full 3.8%, and investing has to earn 5.96% to keep up. After your AOW age the relief is also worth little on a small income: the first bracket is then 17.85%.

Enter your own numbers, free

More than return

Risk

The interest saving is fixed as long as your rate is fixed. The return on investments is not: in a bad year you lose money, and you still pay box 3 on 6%. The €234 a year from the example is small next to what a stock market can do in a year.

Liquidity

Money in your home is not easy to get out again. Borrowing again only works if the bank agrees, and the interest is only deductible if you borrow to buy or improve your home. Investments can be sold whenever you like. If you stop early, you have no salary to fall back on in the years until your AOW; then every euro you can reach counts.

Sequence risk

A sharp fall in the first years after your FIRE date is the biggest risk to your plan. A lower mortgage payment helps then: you need to withdraw less, so you sell less when prices are low. On the other hand, money you used to pay off the mortgage is not there to get you through a bad period. A Monte Carlo simulation shows how that order plays out.

Box 3 is changing

Bill of 3 November 2026 (the amending bill for box 3), not yet law.

The cabinet has dropped its plan to raise the deemed return on investments to 7.87% in 2027. Current law applies in 2027 and 2028. From 2029 the cabinet wants a tax on capital gains: dividends every year, gains only when you sell, with €1,800 tax-free per person and a rate of 35.5% on the first €60,000 a year and 38.5% above that. The House of Representatives approved it on 12 November 2026; the Senate still has to vote. In the years you sell nothing, you then pay less box 3 than now; when you sell, you pay on the whole gain. So how the break-even point moves depends on when you sell.

How to choose

  • The longer you keep working, the more the relief is worth. After your FIRE date it often disappears.
  • Keep enough within reach for the years until your AOW age; see retiring early.
  • Look at your fixed-rate period. If it ends soon, the new rate can change the calculation.
  • Check how much you can overpay without a penalty. It is in the terms of your mortgage.